home
apply diary
archive groups
contact members

MGMS Young Modellers' Forum
with the RSC MMG

Date: Friday, December 1st 2000
Location: Scientific Societies Lecture Theatre, New Burlington Place, Off Savile Row, London W1X 1AB

Timetable

09.30 - 10.00

Registration
10.00 - 10.05
Introduction (David Manallack)
10.05 - 10.10 Introduction to the RSC MMG (Darren Flower)
10.10 - 10.30 Stuart Rison The evolution and structural anatomy of small molecule metabolism pathways in Escherichia coli
10.30 - 10.50 Kelly Paine BACBIX
10.50 - 11.10 Paul Watson Knowledge based functional group similarity
11.10 - 11.30 Miklos Vargyas Three-dimensional flexible database searching using interval analysis
11.30 - 11.50 Anselm Horn Vancomycin dimer formation and binding to a model peptide - A theoretical study
11.50 - 12.10 Yana Dobrogorskaya Quantum chemical studies of reactions of the 1,1'-azobiscarbamide with the zinc finger domains in the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NCp7)
12.10 - 13.30
Lunch
13.30 - 13.50 Szabolcs Csepregi The SPA docking method
13.50 - 14.10 Krisztina Boda Generating synthetically accessible ligands by de novo design
14.10 - 14.30 Christina Grindon Porting the AMBER forcefield to LAMMPS - massively parallel molecular dynamics simulations of DNA
14.30 - 14.50 M.B. Ulmschneider Computer simulations of the 7 TM a-helices of Bacteriorhodopsin
14.50 - 14.20
Coffee
15.20 - 15.40 Andrew Worgan STOP! You're killing me! - (Mechanistic QSAR investigations of a new acute environmental toxicological assay)
15.40 - 16.00 Maria Hinaje The mode of action of destruxins, and their structure/activity relationship (SARs)
16.00 - 16.15 Presentation Skills (David Manallack)
16.15 - 16.30 Mystery Talk (Mystery Speaker)
16.30 - 16.40
Judges deliberations
16.40 - 17.00
Prizes
17.00 onwards
Networking down the pub

 


Abstracts

Stuart Rison
The evolution and structural anatomy of Small Molecule Metabolism pathways in Escherichia coli.
Department of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University College London

Sufficient sequence, structure and functional data are now available for a thorough examination of Escherichia coli small molecule metabolic (SMM) pathways.

We assigned putative structural assignments to over three-quarters of the gene products in E. coli SMM pathways using a number of strategies (including BLAST, PSI-BLAST and SAM-T99 HMM searches).

From these assignments we clarified the domain structure and, evolutionary relationships between SMM genes. In turn, we determined the extent to which domains are duplicated within and across pathways and have combined in enzymes. We also investigated which functional features are conserved in families of homologues.

We consider the evolution of enzymes and pathways in the light of this new information.

back to top


Kelly Paine
BACBIX
The Edward Jenner Institute for Vaccine Research

BACterial BIoinformatiCS/X describes the use of computational biology to identify novel microbial targets. There is a need for more research into the field, as the number of newly published pathogenic genomes grows at an alarming rate. Coupled with conventional in vitro/vivo studies, an in silico approach can drastically speed up the hunt for identifying pathogenic proteins as potential drug and vaccine targets. Antibiotic resistance and lateral transfer amongst pathogens have become major problems. Virulence factors and pathogenicity islands have emerged as good candidates, as they are found exclusively in virulent bacterial strains [1].

Our focus at the Edward Jenner Institute is on bacterial virulence factors as potential vaccine targets. Areas of homology between related proteins can indicate a shared function, and fingerprinting methodologies like PRINTS [2] can elucidate protein families based on key conserved sequence areas, or "motifs". Used in conjunction with known structures, this approach to classifying proteins is both straightforward and simple. Weak homologues can be grouped with relative ease, and there is a considerable reduction in background noise. So far, approx. 50 entries have been submitted to the PRINTS database, with more expected. In addition, an in-house collaboration analysing Pseudomonas proteins has produced at least two potential proteins for further in vitro work.

The title also lends itself to a planned online database of virulence factors. BACBIX will be a web-based collection of protein entries and in silico tools dealing specifically with microbial proteins of pathogenic importance. Another collaboration with Dr. T. Attwood's group at Manchester will generate an entry method designed to create PRINTS fingerprints automatically. Speculative modelling of bacterial porins [3] essential for membrane transport is also envisaged.

To summarise, there is a need for novel in silico tools to analyse the wealth of microbial genome sequence available at present. Quick identification of potential vaccine/drug targets through the use of bacterial bioinformatics (BacBix) coupled to more traditional methods should prove successful. We have identified novel targets, and are in the process of carrying out further work on these moieties.

References
1. Hueck, C.J (1998) Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 329-433
2. Atwood, T.K., Croning, M.D.R., Flower, D.R., Lewis, A.P., Mabey, J.E., Scordis, P., Selley, J. and Wright W. (2000) Nucleic Acids Res 28:225-227.
3. Koebnik, R., Locher, K.P. and Van Gelder, P. (2000) Mol Microbiol 37:239-253.

back to top


Paul Watson
Knowledge Based Functional Group Similarity
Krebs Institute for Biomolecular Research, Department of Information Studies, University of Sheffield
Similarity searching usually involves the specification of a target molecule that exhibits some form of biological activity and results in retrieval of biosterically similar molecules. The search itself compares user defined characteristics of the target molecule with that of the other molecules within the database and calculates a measure of similarity based on those properties. The retrieval of biosterically similar molecules has become a key stage in the rational development of new pharmaceuticals, and as such much interest is shown in the development for new methods/descriptors for their retrieval.

Protein-ligand interactions are fundamental for any sort of biological activity. Therefore calculation of the similarity between groups based upon non-bonded contacts is a useful measure of the ability of one functional group to act as a biosteric replacement for another.

IsoStar is the definitive database of experimental and theoretical information on non-bonded interactions. The experimental information contained within the database is derived from the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD) and the Protein Data Bank (PDB). Information is presented in the form of scatterplots that show the spatial distribution of non-bonded contacts between two chemical groupings.

Using the IsoStar scatterplots, the three-dimensional similarity of the functional groups (central groups) contained within the database are calculated based upon the spatial distribution and density of the contact groups. Scatterplots can be converted to propensity maps for specific probe atoms in a contact group. The propensity maps are compared by superimposing the central groups in a chemically relevant fashion. The similarity is calculated based upon the degree of overlap of the propensity maps. This procedure has been carried out for all the central groups in IsoStar.

The results of these similarity calculations are validated using the Bioster database by comparing the similarities for known biosteric functional groups with those for random pairs of functional groups. The results show a marked difference in the similarities of the random pairs versus the known biosteric pairs, indicating that the IsoStar propensity maps are a good descriptor of three-dimensional similarity.

back to top


Miklós Vargyas
Three-dimensional Flexible Database Searching Using Interval Analysis

School of Chemistry The University of Leeds

Searching structural databases for occurrences of a query pharmacophore is one of the oldest techniques used in rational drug design, dating back to mid 70s. From early methods, that were limited by the use of only one rigid, usually low energy conformation it took 20 years to develop flexible conformational search techniques. These latter methods can carry out searches which are noticeably more effective, but at the expense of a significant increase in the amount of the computer time required. However, even these methods, which in most cases operate by adjusting torsional angles to match the query, cannot guarantee that a matching conformation of a particular compound is found, since they do not consider all possibilities (e.g. because of their use of local optimisation).

A method that uses an exhaustive analysis of the conformational space of a ligand molecule, and is capable to delivering a guarantee of this type will be presented. This method, based on interval analysis (an evolving field of mathematics) uses a continuous representation and search technique without the need of particular discrete sample points. As a result, failure to find a given pharmacophoric pattern in a ligand means, that no such conformation does exists. On the other hand, if there are suitable conformations, then all of them are found.

The effectiveness of this novel method will be demonstrated using three and four point pharmacophores.

back to top


Anselm Horn
Vancomycin Dimer Formation and Binding to a Model Peptide - A Theoretical Study
Computer Chemie Centrum, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg

Multiple drug resistance of Gram-positive bacteria is a serious problem in current medicinal treatment of infections. Thus, vancomycin glycopeptide antibiotics have gained in clinical importance. Experimental results lead to the assumption that the dimerisation of vancomycin (V1:V2) is responsible for enhanced activity due to a stronger binding of the terminal -L-Lys-D-Ala-D-Ala sequence of the precursor peptide of the growing bacterial cell wall.[1,2]

Because the exact nature of the binding mechanism is not known - electronic polarisation is thought to play a key role - MO calculations using the semiempirical program package VAMP[3] were carried out in order to study the influence of the dimerisation upon peptide binding.

Our calculations show that the dimerisation induces considerable polarisation in the peptide binding area of the free monomeric unit by influencing one specific interaction site. To investigate the binding mechanism in detail a model peptide (Ac-D-Ala-D-Ala; AcAA) was chosen and docked to vancomycin.

Furthermore, a discussion of solvation effects upon of vancomycin monomer (V2), dimer (V1:V2) and dimer peptide complex (V1:V2:AcAA) will complement the analysis of the gas phase electrostatics.


Vancomycin monomer and model peptide Ac-D-Ala-A-Ala

References
[1] Mackay, J.P.; Gerhard, U.; Beauregard, D.A.; Maplestone, R.A.; Williams, D.H. J.Am.Chem.Soc. 1994, 116, 4573-4580
[2] Mackay, J.P.; Gerhard, U.; Beauregard, D.A.; Westwell, M.S.; Searle, M.S.; Williams, D.H. J.Am.Chem.Soc. 1994, 116, 4581-4590 and references therein.
[3] Clark, T.; Alex, A.; Beck, B.; Chandrasekhar, J.; Gedeck, P.; Horn, A.; Hutter, M.; Martin, B.; Rauhut, G.; Sauer, S.; Schindler, T.; Steinke, T. VAMP 7.5, Erlangen, 2000.

back to top


Yana Dobrogorskaya
Quantum chemical studies of reactions of the 1,1'-azobiscarbamide with the zinc finger domains in the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NCp7).
Moscow State University, Chemistry Department


Using ab initio calculations based on RHF method the reaction profile of the interaction of 1,1'-azobiscarbonate with the zinc finger domains in the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NCp7) was studied. For this reaction the reagent affinities to the electron were estimated. Using effective core potentials, the geometry of the zinc finger domain was optimized. Equilibrium geometry corresponds to the tetrahedral coordination of the zinc domain. It is supposed that both zis- and trans-1,1'-azobiscarbonates are efficient agents to destroy the tetrahedral coordination sphere of zinc finger domain. It is found that one possible way of the reaction deals with the breaking of the Zn-S bond and the S(CH3)-group removing.

back to top


Szabolcs Csepregi
The SPA docking method
ICAMS, School of Chemistry, University of Leeds

An empirical scoring function and a flexible molecular docking method based on it are being developed at the University of Leeds.

The scoring function contains elements describing Van der Waals, hydrogen bonding, metal ion bonding, hydrophobic, rotatable bond entropy and dihedral strain energy terms. The coefficients of different terms are obtained by regression analysis based on a training set of 50 protein-ligand complexes from The Protein Data Bank. The scoring function also comprises a novel building of a hydrogen and metal bonding framework within the receptor-ligand complex by rotating the terminal rotatable bonds to achieve optimal hydrogen and metal bonding geometries.

The docking method is based on a novel simulated annealing minimization algorithm called Systematic Population Annealing (SPA) which has been developed in our laboratory and applied to the scoring function above. During the optimization the ligand is treated flexible by rotating around internal single bonds and the receptor is kept rigid, apart from the terminal bonds above.

The presentation will provide an overview of the scoring and docking methods of SPA, will also show some results and compare it to other docking methods.

back to top


Krisztina Boda
Generating synthetically accessible ligands by De Novo Design
School of Chemistry, University of Leeds

One of the deficiencies of De Novo molecular structure design programs is that after a time and memory consuming structure generation process, many of the solutions produced may not be synthetically accessible.

The approach used in Synthetic Sprout (SYNSPROUT), a new variant of SPROUT, is to build synthetic constraints into the structure generation process by starting with a library of readily available starting materials, which are used in the initial docking and building up process. This process only permits joins which correspond exactly to chemical reactions from a user created knowledge base.

The current version of the program works well with medium sized databases of starting materials. For large databases such as ACD, the combinatorial nature of the structure generation process means that even the recently developed parallel version would be too slow and work in hand is geared to overcoming this problem.

The presentation will provide an overview of the main concepts and problems together with examples of the system in action.

back to top


Christina Grindon
Porting the AMBER forcefield to LAMMPS - massively parallel molecular dynamics simulations of DNA

Cancer Research Laboratories, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Nottingham
, University Park, Nottingham, NG7 2RD. .
Molecular Dynamics (MD) is proving to be a valuable method for analysing the structure and flexibility of DNA [1]. Its major draw back is the relatively short timescales which can be simulated due to the high computing cost. At present atomistic MD simulations of DNA using conventional algorithms are limited in practice to around 10ns [2]. There are important motions within DNA which are predicted to occur over longer timescales than this eg. base pair breathing.

LAMMPS (Large Atomic/Molecular Massively Parallel Simulator) [3,4] is a parallel MD code with accurate treatment of long-range electrostatic interactions, and the potential to generate simulations up to the 100ns timescale with current supercomputers. We have successfully ported the AMBER forcefield for DNA to LAMMPS and performed initial bench marking studies.

Short (10ps) simulations indicate that the code scales linearly with increasing number of processors (tested to 64), in contrast to AMBER which performs much more poorly in parallel situations.

Static energy analysis of conformations of the DNA dodecamer CTTTTGCAAAAG shows excellent agreement between AMBER and LAMMPS. MD simulations (up to 3ns) show stable dynamics and RMS atomic fluctuations in line with previous AMBER results on the same sequence. However, on closer inspection of the trajectory data there are some inconsistancies between AMBER and LAMMPS. The LAMMPS simulations show lower entropies than AMBER and localised motions are found from Principal Component Analysis (PCA). We attribute this to an over-tight temperature scaling parameter. More simulations are being carried out using different temperature scaling parameters to find an optimal value which gives results more comparable to AMBER. Comparable entropies and PCA results will confirm how well the overall dynamics of the DNA is preserved between the two simulation methods.

References
[1] Sherer EC, Harris SA, Soliva R, Orozco M, Laughton CA, J.Am.Chem.Soc, 1999, 121, p5981-5991.
[2] Cubero E, Sherer EC, Luque FJ, Orozco M, Laughton CA, J.Am.Chem.Soc, 1999, 121, p8653-8654.
[3] Plimpton S.J, Hendrickson B.A, J.Comp.Chem, 1996, 17, p326-337.
[4] Plimpton S.J, Pollock R, Stevens M, Proc of the 8th SIAM Conference on Parallel Processing for Scientific Computing, Minneapolis,MN. March 1997.

back to top


M.B. Ulmschneider
Computer Simulations of the 7 TM a-helices of Bacteriorhodopsin
University of Oxford
Bacteriorhodopsin is one of the most intensively studied membrane proteins and has been the subject of many structural studies and computer simulations. There are currently 26 complete X-ray and EM structures in the PDB protein database, more than for any other membrane protein. Bacteriorhodopsin therefore represents the ideal test case for simulation methods and protocols. Molecular dynamics simulations of the individual a-helices were carried out in various simulation environments and set-ups. Different membrane mimics (octane, lipids and water), system sizes, the treatment of the termini (capped / uncapped) and the application of heavy Hydrogen and dummy atom methods to increase the simulation timestep were investigated in 10ns molecular dynamics simulations. Results were compared to both previous simulations and the currently available structures. The findings were also compared to simulations with a similar set-up for the whole protein. Properties investigated in this study include the sampling of conformational space and the interaction of the helices with the membrane mimic and solvent.

back to top


Andrew Worgan
STOP! You're killing me! (Mechanistic QSAR investigations of a new acute environmental toxicological assay)
School of Pharmacy and Chemistry Liverpool John Moores University
A novel ecotoxicological assay has been developed which measures the toxicity of industrial organic compounds to the green alga Chlorella vulgaris. Non-specific esterases within the alga convert the non fluorigenic fluorescein diacetate to the fluorogenic compound fluorescein. This conversion may be analysed and quantified using simple fluorimetry. The addition of toxicants to the alga suspension suppresses the cells functionality and therefore its enzymatic activity. This may be seen as a lessening in the production of fluorescein and dose-response curves may be generated for each compound tested. This assay has the advantage of being rapid (15 minutes) and very inexpensive.

Approximately 90 compounds representing several mechanisms of toxicological action have been tested using this assay and the data analysed using mechanistic Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationships (QSARs).

QSAR analysis has shown that, in general, the 15 minute acute algal assay under development produces results which may be quantified using traditional physico-chemical parameters such as Log KOW and ELUMO and produces results similar to those generated by other toxicological methodologies.

It has also been shown that each mechanism of action produces QSAR equations using between 10 and 20 compounds which are comparable to other QSAR studies using many more compounds.

back to top


Maria Hinaje
The mode of action of destruxins,and their structure/activity relationship (SARs)
University of Portsmouth

The destruxins are hexacyclopdepsipeptidicmycotoxins produced by the entomogenous fungus Metarzhium anisoplae. These natural products are considered "vivotoxins" because they are produced during the fungal infection of a host. The lethal effect of destruxins is associated in leptidopteran insects with a paralysis, that results from a depolarization of the muscle cell membrane. This depolarisation results from opening of endogenous calcium channels (Samuels et al., 1988). Significant differences in biological response to a set of destruxins have been reported, in spite of apparently minor differences in the structural chemistry of this group (Dumas et al., 1994). However, the relationships between structure and the activity among these cyclic peptides has not yet been elucidated. The principal objective of the project is to identify the mode of action of destruxins in order to make an accurate comparison of the cytotoxic action of the different destruxins using the modelling package Quanta. The modelling studies have been validated by experimentation using liposomes and dye indicators. Another aim is to establish SARs for the set of molecules reported by Dumas (1994) and to identify the structural features that determine the toxicity. Armed with this knowledge, a programme of chemical synthesis is planned to discover more effective materials for use as agrochemicals.

back to top


site designed and maintained by Graham Tyrrell